$415,000
Active
$415,000
8887 225th
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2.5 ba1,526 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Gee
Cutler Bay, FL
Cutler Cay Homes for Sale
Browse active MLS listings in Cutler Cay, Cutler Bay, FL. Local expertise, free buyer representation, 1% listing commission.
—
Community Type
Cutler Cay — Active Listings
224 active listings
$2,499,000
Active
$2,499,000
8000 184th
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
3 bd1.5 ba1,709 sqft
Perrine Grant Sub
$999,000
Active
$999,000
10130 Bahia
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
4 bd3 ba2,533 sqft
Capistrano
$408,000
Active
1d
$408,000
22913 99th
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2.5 ba1,362 sqft
Enclave South Phase 2
$249,000
Active
1d
$249,000
8660 212th #305
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
1 bd1 ba813 sqft
Le Club At Old Cutler Con
$339,000
Active
$339,000
22911 88th #721
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2.5 ba1,383 sqft
The Courts At Bayshore I
$650,000
Active
5d
$650,000
10315 200th
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
5 bd3 ba2,278 sqft
Bel-Aire Sec 2
$689,000
Active
4d
$689,000
20210 106th
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
4 bd2 ba1,534 sqft
Benson Manor
$649,000
Active
1d
$649,000
18670 Belview
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
4 bd2 ba1,972 sqft
Bel-Aire Sec 1
No photo available
$649,000
Active
$649,000
20010 111th
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
3 bd2 ba1,633 sqft
So Miami Heights Addn N
$399,999
Active
6d
$399,999
9315 221st
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
2 bd2.5 ba1,282 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Cee
$399,900
Active
6d
$399,900
20930 83rd
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
2 bd2.5 ba1,381 sqft
Saga Bay Townhomes
$865,000
Active
6d
$865,000
7950 196th
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
4 bd2.5 ba2,324 sqft
Saga Bay Sec 1 Pt 4
$589,999
Active
7d
$589,999
19601 Belview
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
4 bd2 ba1,288 sqft
Bel-Aire Sec 2
$599,999
Active
6d
$599,999
21462 91st
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
4 bd2 ba1,561 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Sec 8
$600,000
Active
$600,000
19310 Christmas
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
3 bd1 ba1,125 sqft
Pine Tree Manor Sec 4
$497,000
Active
8d
$497,000
22256 89th
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2.5 ba1,812 sqft
Lakes By The Bay
$640,000
Active
9d
$640,000
22732 92nd
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
5 bd3 ba2,916 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Faye Rep
$579,500
Active
9d
$579,500
20921 Coral Sea
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
3 bd2 ba1,364 sqft
Cutler Ridge Sec 3
$495,000
Active
4d
$495,000
10003 223rd
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
4 bd2 ba1,626 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Sec 6
$236,900
Active
10d
$236,900
8200 210th #111
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
2 bd2 ba980 sqft
Saga Bay Gardens Condo
$225,000
Active
$225,000
8600 212th #208
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
1 bd1 ba813 sqft
Le Club At Old Cutler Con
$1,196,000
Active
11d
$1,196,000
7563 188th
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
4 bd3.5 ba2,723 sqft
Cutler Cay
$347,300
Active
2d
$347,300
22721 88th #919
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2.5 ba1,383 sqft
The Courts At Bayshore I
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Cutler Cay — Recent Sales
8,900 recent sales
$1,200,000
Closed
6d
$1,200,000
7944 187
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
5 bd3 ba2,935 sqft
Cutler Country Groves
$585,000
Closed
11d
$585,000
19411 Gulfstream
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
3 bd2 ba1,652 sqft
Pine Tree Manor Sec 4
$625,000
Closed
12d
$625,000
9256 209th
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
4 bd2 ba1,620 sqft
C B Palms
$750,000
Closed
$750,000
7964 199th
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
3 bd2 ba1,764 sqft
Saga Bay Sec 1 Pt 9
$255,000
Closed
17d
$255,000
8680 212th #105
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
2 bd2 ba1,113 sqft
Le Club At Old Cutler Con
$470,000
Closed
8d
$470,000
19460 87th
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
3 bd2 ba1,597 sqft
Mark Manor Pines Sec One
$550,000
Closed
35d
$550,000
20401 83rd
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
3 bd2 ba1,877 sqft
Saga Bay Sec 1
$769,000
Closed
49d
$769,000
9001 197th
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
5 bd3 ba2,858 sqft
Whispering Pines Est Sec
$630,000
Closed
2d
$630,000
18535 90th
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
3 bd2 ba1,953 sqft
Bel Aire Sec 11
$249,900
Closed
18d
$249,900
8590 212th #303
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
2 bd2 ba1,113 sqft
Le Club At Old Cutler Con
$677,000
Closed
6d
$677,000
9500 Caribbean
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
3 bd3 ba2,664 sqft
South Coral Homes Sec 2
$999,000
Closed
11d
$999,000
7749 184th
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
4 bd2.5 ba2,770 sqft
Cutler Country Groves Pla
$389,900
Closed
18d
$389,900
8546 214th
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
3 bd2.5 ba1,295 sqft
Santa Barbara
$575,000
Closed
8d
$575,000
21200 92nd
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
4 bd2 ba2,078 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Sec 10
$580,000
Closed
23d
$580,000
9928 218th
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2 ba1,425 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Sec 2
$499,000
Closed
21d
$499,000
9786 222nd
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2 ba1,369 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Sec 5
$719,000
Closed
3d
$719,000
8550 208th
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
4 bd3 ba2,020 sqft
Centennial Sec 2
$497,999
Closed
3d
$497,999
8875 227th
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2.5 ba1,787 sqft
Trellis At Bayshore
$515,000
Closed
3d
$515,000
19225 Franjo #1
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
3 bd2 ba1,104 sqft
Whispering Pines Est Sec 4
$699,000
Closed
9d
$699,000
20918 89th
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
3 bd2.5 ba2,128 sqft
Pelican Bay At Old Cutler
$575,000
Closed
5d
$575,000
9401 Jamaica
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
3 bd2 ba1,501 sqft
South Coral Homes Sec 2
$590,000
Closed
17d
$590,000
9473 227th
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2.5 ba1,749 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Day
$574,500
Closed
38d
$574,500
10060 214th
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
4 bd2 ba1,440 sqft
Cutler Ridge Sec 7
$999,000
Closed
5d
$999,000
8125 184th
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
3 bd2.5 ba2,040 sqft
Eureka Drive Estates
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Home Valuation
What is Your Cutler Cay Home Worth?
Get a free, no-obligation home valuation from our local Cutler Bay specialists. We'll analyze recent sales and current market conditions to give you an accurate estimate.
Mortgage Pre-Approval
Get Pre-Approved to Buy in Cutler Cay
Mortgage Capital: FHA, VA, Conventional, Jumbo, DSCR, Non-QM
Looking for Cutler Cay homes for sale? Pure Equity Realty covers Cutler Cay and the Cutler Bay, Florida market. We charge 1% listing commission for sellers and provide free buyer representation. Our local agents know this community and can arrange showings within 24 hours.
About Cutler Cay
Cutler Cay Community Guide
Cutler Cay is a community in Cutler Bay, Miami-Dade County, Florida. Active listings are priced from $840,000 to $2.2M. Homes were built between 2004 and 2007. Pure Equity Realty lists homes in Cutler Cay for 1% commission and represents buyers at no cost.
Pure Equity Realty covers Cutler Cay and the Cutler Bay area. We list for 1%, which includes photography, MLS syndication, and negotiation support. Buyers pay nothing for representation. For current market data, see Florida Realtors' market statistics.
South Florida MLS
Featured Cutler Cay Homes for Sale
224 active listings
$415,000
Active
$415,000
8887 225th
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2.5 ba1,526 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Gee
$2,499,000
Active
$2,499,000
8000 184th
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
3 bd1.5 ba1,709 sqft
Perrine Grant Sub
$999,000
Active
$999,000
10130 Bahia
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
4 bd3 ba2,533 sqft
Capistrano
$408,000
Active
1d
$408,000
22913 99th
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2.5 ba1,362 sqft
Enclave South Phase 2
$249,000
Active
1d
$249,000
8660 212th #305
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
1 bd1 ba813 sqft
Le Club At Old Cutler Con
$339,000
Active
$339,000
22911 88th #721
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2.5 ba1,383 sqft
The Courts At Bayshore I
$650,000
Active
5d
$650,000
10315 200th
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
5 bd3 ba2,278 sqft
Bel-Aire Sec 2
$689,000
Active
4d
$689,000
20210 106th
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
4 bd2 ba1,534 sqft
Benson Manor
$649,000
Active
1d
$649,000
18670 Belview
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
4 bd2 ba1,972 sqft
Bel-Aire Sec 1
No photo available
$649,000
Active
$649,000
20010 111th
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
3 bd2 ba1,633 sqft
So Miami Heights Addn N
$399,999
Active
6d
$399,999
9315 221st
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
2 bd2.5 ba1,282 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Cee
$399,900
Active
6d
$399,900
20930 83rd
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
2 bd2.5 ba1,381 sqft
Saga Bay Townhomes
$865,000
Active
6d
$865,000
7950 196th
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
4 bd2.5 ba2,324 sqft
Saga Bay Sec 1 Pt 4
$589,999
Active
7d
$589,999
19601 Belview
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
4 bd2 ba1,288 sqft
Bel-Aire Sec 2
$599,999
Active
6d
$599,999
21462 91st
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
4 bd2 ba1,561 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Sec 8
$600,000
Active
$600,000
19310 Christmas
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
3 bd1 ba1,125 sqft
Pine Tree Manor Sec 4
$497,000
Active
8d
$497,000
22256 89th
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2.5 ba1,812 sqft
Lakes By The Bay
$640,000
Active
9d
$640,000
22732 92nd
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
5 bd3 ba2,916 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Faye Rep
$579,500
Active
9d
$579,500
20921 Coral Sea
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
3 bd2 ba1,364 sqft
Cutler Ridge Sec 3
$495,000
Active
4d
$495,000
10003 223rd
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
4 bd2 ba1,626 sqft
Lakes By The Bay Sec 6
$236,900
Active
10d
$236,900
8200 210th #111
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
2 bd2 ba980 sqft
Saga Bay Gardens Condo
$225,000
Active
$225,000
8600 212th #208
Cutler Bay, FL 33189
1 bd1 ba813 sqft
Le Club At Old Cutler Con
$1,196,000
Active
11d
$1,196,000
7563 188th
Cutler Bay, FL 33157
4 bd3.5 ba2,723 sqft
Cutler Cay
$347,300
Active
2d
$347,300
22721 88th #919
Cutler Bay, FL 33190
3 bd2.5 ba1,383 sqft
The Courts At Bayshore I
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Amenities & Community Details
Cutler Cay Amenities
Active Price Range
$165K–$3.5M
Cutler Cay is a residential community in Cutler Bay. Call (561) 835-5400 for a current amenities list and availability.
Location & Map
Cutler Cay Location
Map is approximate. Contact us for exact community boundaries.
View on Google Maps →Frequently Asked Questions
Cutler Cay FAQ
What type of community is Cutler Cay?+
Cutler Cay is a residential community in Cutler Bay, Florida.
What is the price range in Cutler Cay?+
Homes in Cutler Cay are currently listed from $165K–$3.5M. Prices shift with market conditions. Contact us or set a listing alert on this page for real-time availability and accurate pricing from our local Cutler Bay specialists.
Does Cutler Cay allow rentals?+
Cutler Cay currently restricts rentals per HOA rules. This is common in 55+ and gated communities. Exceptions and waiting lists may exist. Contact us for the most up-to-date rental policy details.
How do I schedule a showing in Cutler Cay?+
Call us at (561) 835-5400 or use the listing alert form on this page. Our agents specialize in Cutler Cay and the broader Cutler Bay market and can typically arrange private showings within 24 hours, including evenings and weekends.
More Cutler Bay Real Estate
Condos in Cutler BayWaterfront Homes in Cutler BayGated Communities in Cutler BayGolf Communities in Cutler Bay55+ Communities in Cutler BayNew Construction Homes in Cutler BayLuxury Homes in Cutler BayOceanfront Properties in Cutler BayEquestrian Communities in Cutler BayTennis Communities in Cutler Bay
Cutler Bay Property Types & Special Listings
Bank-Owned Homes (REOs) in Cutler BayShort Sales in Cutler BayMulti-Family Homes in Cutler BayDuplexes in Cutler BayTriplexes in Cutler BayQuadplexes in Cutler BayMobile & Manufactured Homes in Cutler BayHUD Homes in Cutler BayFor Sale By Owner in Cutler BayForeclosures in Cutler BayHome Auctions in Cutler BayRent to Own Homes in Cutler Bay
Locations near Cutler Cay
Cantamar Homes for SaleEnclave South Phase 2 Homes for SaleLakes By The Bay Jay Homes for SaleLakes By The Bay Sec 9 Am Homes for SaleOld Cutler Cove Addn Homes for SaleBel-Aire Sec 1 Homes for SaleBel-Aire Sec 2 Homes for SaleBel Aire Sec 3 Homes for SaleBlack Creek Villas Homes for SaleCapistrano Homes for SaleCentury At Cutler Bay Homes for SaleCutler Ridge Sec 3 Homes for SaleCutler Ridge Sec 4 Homes for SaleEnclave At Black Point Ma Homes for SaleLakes By The Bay Cee Homes for SaleLakes By The Bay Eve Repl Homes for SaleLakes By The Bay Gee Homes for SaleLakes By The Bay Kaye Homes for SaleLakes By The Bay Sec 3 Homes for SaleLakes By The Bay Sec 5 Homes for SaleLakes By The Bay Sec 6 Homes for SaleLakes By The Bay Sec 7 Homes for SaleLakes By The Bay Sec 8 Homes for SaleOld Cutler Cove Homes for SaleOld Cutler Grove Homes for SaleOmni Estates 2nd Addn Homes for SalePelican Bay At Old Cutler Homes for SalePerrine Grant Sub Homes for SalePine Tree Manor Sec 4 Homes for SaleS Coral Homes Sec 3 Homes for SaleSaga Bay Sec 1 Homes for SaleSaga Bay Sec One Part Two Homes for SaleSaga Bay Townhomes Homes for SaleSanta Barbara Homes for SaleSouth Coral Homes Sec 2 Homes for SaleThe Courts At Bayshore I Homes for SaleThe Courts At Bayshore Ii Homes for SaleThe Shores Condo No 1 Homes for SaleThe Shores Condo No 2 Homes for SaleWhispering Pines Est Sec Homes for SaleWhispering Pines Estates Homes for Sale
Looking to Rent?
Browse all rental listings in Cutler Bay, FL, including homes near Cutler Cay.