$534,999
Active
$534,999
5532 GRAHAM
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2.5 ba2,495 sqft
Martins Crossing
Stuart, FL
Sailfish Cay Homes for Sale
Browse active MLS listings in Sailfish Cay, Stuart, FL. Local expertise, free buyer representation, 1% listing commission.
—
Community Type
Sailfish Cay — Active Listings
397 active listings
$494,990
Active
$494,990
737 Central #10
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2.5 ba1,497 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$514,990
Active
$514,990
737 Central #5
Stuart, FL 34994
4 bd2.5 ba1,915 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$534,490
Active
$534,490
737 Central #12
Stuart, FL 34994
4 bd2.5 ba1,915 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$270,000
Active
1d
$270,000
6455 Windsong #105
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2.5 ba1,288 sqft
Emerald Lakes
$514,990
Active
$514,990
737 Central #9
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2.5 ba1,719 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$735,000
Active
$735,000
1428 Summit
Stuart, FL 34997
5 bd4.5 ba3,557 sqft
Cove Lakes Pud
$893,160
Active
$893,160
10400 Highpointe #120 Stellar
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd3 ba2,663 sqft
Highpointe Pud Phase 2
$360,000
Active
$360,000
2802 JANET
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,800 sqft
Brownings
$375,000
Active
1d
$375,000
2038 Monroe
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd3 ba1,340 sqft
Coral Gardens
$1,195,000
Active
$1,195,000
41 Seminole #Unit #3-10
Stuart, FL 34994
2 bd2 ba1,313 sqft
Sailfish Cove Luxury Newes
$274,000
Active
1d
$274,000
5606 Riverboat
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2.5 ba1,288 sqft
River Pines
$484,990
Active
$484,990
737 Central #11
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2.5 ba1,497 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$285,000
Active
2d
$285,000
2659 Monarch
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2 ba1,232 sqft
St Lucie Falls (Aka River Forest)
$494,990
Active
$494,990
737 Central Parkway #7
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2.5 ba1,497 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$484,990
Active
$484,990
737 Central #8
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2.5 ba1,497 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$335,000
Active
$335,000
5709 Indigo
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd1 ba1,388 sqft
Hibiscus Park
$154,444
Active
2d
$154,444
950 KANNER HWY TH-133 #133
Stuart, FL 34994
2 bd2.5 ba1,250 sqft
Poppleton Creek Condo
$325,000
Active
$325,000
913 FORREST PARK
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2 ba1,058 sqft
Forrest Park
$358,000
Active
$358,000
4675 Circle
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,248 sqft
Port Salerno Estates
$515,000
Active
2d
$515,000
2184 WASHINGTON
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,404 sqft
Coral Gardens
$265,000
Active
$265,000
1600 Saint Lucie #110
Stuart, FL 34996
2 bd2 ba1,370 sqft
Banyan House Condo
$299,000
Active
$299,000
5132 CLUB #202
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2 ba1,358 sqft
Mariner Sands Club Villas Condo
$160,000
Active
$160,000
4432 Sweetwood
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,482 sqft
Pinelake Gardens And Estates
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Sailfish Cay — Recent Sales
12,866 recent sales
$425,000
Closed
$425,000
4849 GRAHAM
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,717 sqft
Martins Crossing
$159,000
Closed
4d
$159,000
1950 Palm City #10106
Stuart, FL 34994
1 bd1.5 ba900 sqft
Circle Bay Yacht Club Condo
$374,900
Closed
4d
$374,900
5124 Schooner Oaks
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,600 sqft
Schooner Oaks Condo
$400,000
Closed
7d
$400,000
2370 Ocean #C-101
Stuart, FL 34996
2 bd2 ba1,316 sqft
Ocean View
$550,000
Closed
8d
$550,000
3392 Porpoise
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba2,184 sqft
River Marina
$425,000
Closed
7d
$425,000
2446 Hideaway
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd1.5 ba1,097 sqft
Fishermans Hideaway Section One
$369,900
Closed
8d
$369,900
2920 Cypress
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2 ba1,320 sqft
Hibiscus Park
$415,000
Closed
7d
$415,000
2456 Hideaway
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd1.5 ba1,097 sqft
Fishermans Hideaway Section One
$4,900,000
Closed
4d
$4,900,000
1771 Saint Lucie
Stuart, FL 34996
4 bd5.5 ba5,314 sqft
Golfview
$255,000
Closed
15d
$255,000
5433 Miles Grant #201
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2 ba1,186 sqft
Miles Grant Condo
$899,000
Closed
10d
$899,000
4599 Halston
Stuart, FL 34997
4 bd3.5 ba2,999 sqft
B L Steinberg Development
$2,495,000
Closed
2d
$2,495,000
2236 Fork
Stuart, FL 34994
4 bd4.5 ba3,557 sqft
North River Shores
$729,995
Closed
4d
$729,995
6794 Lost Pine
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2.5 ba2,026 sqft
Salerno Reserve At Showcase Pud
$319,900
Closed
6d
$319,900
3410 Martinique #102
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2 ba1,506 sqft
Montego Cove Condo A
$1,075,000
Closed
1d
$1,075,000
512 South Carolina
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2 ba2,064 sqft
Palmetto Harbor
$265,000
Closed
3d
$265,000
175 St Lucie #D-2
Stuart, FL 34996
2 bd2 ba1,300 sqft
Pierpoint Yacht Club Condo
$425,000
Closed
3d
$425,000
5251 Sea Island
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2 ba1,173 sqft
Fairway Villas Of Miles Grant Condo
$559,000
Closed
15d
$559,000
4819 Mariner Village
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,826 sqft
Mariner Village
$587,000
Closed
14d
$587,000
4240 Happy
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,839 sqft
Rainbow Cove
$299,900
Closed
11d
$299,900
461 Bloxham
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2.5 ba1,296 sqft
Martins Crossing
$120,000
Closed
16d
$120,000
2929 Ocean #139-7
Stuart, FL 34996
1 bd1.5 ba696 sqft
Cedar Pointe Condo
$375,000
Closed
2d
$375,000
6518 Held
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2 ba1,005 sqft
Vista Salerno Revised
$235,000
Closed
7d
$235,000
6202 Riverboat #941
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2.5 ba1,288 sqft
River Pines
$497,600
Closed
11d
$497,600
5432 50th
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,359 sqft
Sandy Ridge
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Home Valuation
What is Your Sailfish Cay Home Worth?
Get a free, no-obligation home valuation from our local Stuart specialists. We'll analyze recent sales and current market conditions to give you an accurate estimate.
Mortgage Pre-Approval
Get Pre-Approved to Buy in Sailfish Cay
Mortgage Capital: FHA, VA, Conventional, Jumbo, DSCR, Non-QM
Looking for Sailfish Cay homes for sale? Pure Equity Realty covers Sailfish Cay and the Stuart, Florida market. We charge 1% listing commission for sellers and provide free buyer representation. Our local agents know this community and can arrange showings within 24 hours.
About Sailfish Cay
Sailfish Cay Community Guide
Sailfish Cay is a residential community in Stuart, Florida. Active listings are currently priced from $68K–$35M.
Pure Equity Realty covers Sailfish Cay and the Stuart area. We list for 1%, which includes photography, MLS syndication, and negotiation support. Buyers pay nothing for representation. For current market data, see Florida Realtors' market statistics.
South Florida MLS
Featured Sailfish Cay Homes for Sale
397 active listings
$534,999
Active
$534,999
5532 GRAHAM
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2.5 ba2,495 sqft
Martins Crossing
$494,990
Active
$494,990
737 Central #10
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2.5 ba1,497 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$514,990
Active
$514,990
737 Central #5
Stuart, FL 34994
4 bd2.5 ba1,915 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$534,490
Active
$534,490
737 Central #12
Stuart, FL 34994
4 bd2.5 ba1,915 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$270,000
Active
1d
$270,000
6455 Windsong #105
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2.5 ba1,288 sqft
Emerald Lakes
$514,990
Active
$514,990
737 Central #9
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2.5 ba1,719 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$735,000
Active
$735,000
1428 Summit
Stuart, FL 34997
5 bd4.5 ba3,557 sqft
Cove Lakes Pud
$893,160
Active
$893,160
10400 Highpointe #120 Stellar
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd3 ba2,663 sqft
Highpointe Pud Phase 2
$360,000
Active
$360,000
2802 JANET
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,800 sqft
Brownings
$375,000
Active
1d
$375,000
2038 Monroe
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd3 ba1,340 sqft
Coral Gardens
$1,195,000
Active
$1,195,000
41 Seminole #Unit #3-10
Stuart, FL 34994
2 bd2 ba1,313 sqft
Sailfish Cove Luxury Newes
$274,000
Active
1d
$274,000
5606 Riverboat
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2.5 ba1,288 sqft
River Pines
$484,990
Active
$484,990
737 Central #11
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2.5 ba1,497 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$285,000
Active
2d
$285,000
2659 Monarch
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2 ba1,232 sqft
St Lucie Falls (Aka River Forest)
$494,990
Active
$494,990
737 Central Parkway #7
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2.5 ba1,497 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$484,990
Active
$484,990
737 Central #8
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2.5 ba1,497 sqft
Towne Park Replat No. 2
$335,000
Active
$335,000
5709 Indigo
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd1 ba1,388 sqft
Hibiscus Park
$154,444
Active
2d
$154,444
950 KANNER HWY TH-133 #133
Stuart, FL 34994
2 bd2.5 ba1,250 sqft
Poppleton Creek Condo
$325,000
Active
$325,000
913 FORREST PARK
Stuart, FL 34994
3 bd2 ba1,058 sqft
Forrest Park
$358,000
Active
$358,000
4675 Circle
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,248 sqft
Port Salerno Estates
$515,000
Active
2d
$515,000
2184 WASHINGTON
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,404 sqft
Coral Gardens
$265,000
Active
$265,000
1600 Saint Lucie #110
Stuart, FL 34996
2 bd2 ba1,370 sqft
Banyan House Condo
$299,000
Active
$299,000
5132 CLUB #202
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2 ba1,358 sqft
Mariner Sands Club Villas Condo
$160,000
Active
$160,000
4432 Sweetwood
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,482 sqft
Pinelake Gardens And Estates
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Amenities & Community Details
Sailfish Cay Amenities
Active Price Range
$68K–$35M
Sailfish Cay is a residential community in Stuart. Call (561) 835-5400 for a current amenities list and availability.
Schools
Schools Near Sailfish Cay
Elementary
J.D. Parker
Middle
Dr. David L. Anderson
High School
Jensen Beach
School assignments are subject to change. Verify zoning directly with the Palm Beach County School District before purchase.
Location & Map
Sailfish Cay Location
Map is approximate. Contact us for exact community boundaries.
View on Google Maps →Frequently Asked Questions
Sailfish Cay FAQ
What type of community is Sailfish Cay?+
Sailfish Cay is a residential community in Stuart, Florida.
What is the price range in Sailfish Cay?+
Homes in Sailfish Cay are currently listed from $68K–$35M. Prices shift with market conditions. Contact us or set a listing alert on this page for real-time availability and accurate pricing from our local Stuart specialists.
Does Sailfish Cay allow rentals?+
Sailfish Cay currently restricts rentals per HOA rules. This is common in 55+ and gated communities. Exceptions and waiting lists may exist. Contact us for the most up-to-date rental policy details.
How do I schedule a showing in Sailfish Cay?+
Call us at (561) 835-5400 or use the listing alert form on this page. Our agents specialize in Sailfish Cay and the broader Stuart market and can typically arrange private showings within 24 hours, including evenings and weekends.
More Stuart Real Estate
Stuart Property Types & Special Listings
Locations near Sailfish Cay
De La Bahia Homes for SaleFishermans Hideaway Homes for SaleResort Villas Condo 01 & 02 Irp Homes for SaleConquistador Estates Homes for SaleBanyan Tree Estates Homes for SaleBeachwood Villas Homes for SaleEstuary At Nrs Homes for SaleHutchinson House East Homes for SaleKing Mountain Homes for SaleMontego Cove Condo All Homes for SaleSouth River Village Homes for SaleSt Lucie Club Apt Homes Homes for SaleWindjammer Homes for SaleHutchinson House West Homes for SaleSouthwood Pud Homes for SaleMartin'S Crossing Homes for SaleFairmont Estates Homes for Sale800 Place Homes for SaleRio Vista Sub Homes for SaleYacht & Country Club Stuart Homes for SaleFishermans Hideaway Section One Homes for SaleThe Preserve At Avonlea Homes for SaleResort Villas Homes for SaleRiver Forest Homes for SalePreserves At Park Trace Homes for SaleTierra Verde Homes for SaleCoral Gardens Homes for SalePort Sewall (Aka Sewall'S Point Land Co) Homes for Sale593845 Harbor Estates St Lucie Sett Homes for SaleBanyan Bay Homes for SaleBanyan House Condo Homes for SaleBayview Irp Homes for SaleBeau Rivage Homes for SaleBroadway Section Of St Lucie Estates Subdivision Homes for SaleBrook Villas Homes for SaleCastle Hill Homes for SaleCedar Pointe Condo Homes for SaleCircle Bay Yacht Club Homes for SaleConquistador Homes for SaleCoral Gardens Homes for SaleCove At Park Trace Homes for SaleCove Lakes Homes for SaleCove Royale Homes for SaleDixie Park Homes for SaleEdgewater Pointe Homes for SaleEmerald Lakes Homes for SaleFairway Palms Homes for SaleFishermans Cove Homes for SaleFlorida Club Homes for SaleFork River Homes for SaleGardens At Poppleton Creek Homes for SaleGolden Gate Homes for SaleHansons Landing Homes for SaleHarborage Yacht Homes for SaleHibiscus Park Homes for SaleHidden Harbour Homes for SaleHutchinson House Homes for SaleIndian Groves Homes for SaleIndian Pines Homes for SaleIronwood In Mariner Sands Homes for SaleKanner Lake (Aka Willow Pointe) Homes for SaleKing Mountain Condo (Aka Monterey Yacht & Country Homes for SaleKing Mountain Condo Monterey Yacht & Country Club Homes for SaleKingswood Homes for SaleLeisure Village Homes for SaleLexington Lakes Homes for SaleLocks Landing Homes for SaleLost River Manors Homes for SaleManatee Isles Homes for SaleMariner Cay Homes for SaleMariner Sands Club Villas Condo Homes for SaleMariner Sands Country Club Homes for SaleMariner Village Homes for SaleMariner Village Of Martin County Homes for SaleMartins Crossing Homes for SaleMiles Grant Homes for SaleMontego Cove Homes for SaleNatalie Estates Homes for SaleNatalie Estates Mobile Home Park Co Op Homes for SaleNew Monrovia Homes for SaleOcean Cove Homes for SalePalm Lake Park Homes for SalePalmetto Harbor Homes for SalePark Square Condo Aka Country Meadows Homes for SaleParkview Condo Homes for SalePierpoint Yacht Club Cond Homes for SalePinelake Gardens And Estates Homes for SalePinelake Gardens Estates Homes for SalePoppleton Creek Area Homes for SalePort Salerno Homes for SalePort Salerno Village Homes for SaleQueens Park Homes for SaleRiver Glen Homes for SaleRiver Marina Homes for SaleRiver Pines Homes for SaleRiverside Park Homes for SaleRocky Point Homes for SaleRuff'S Little Dixie Homes for SaleSailfish Cove Homes for SaleSandpebble Homes for SaleSandy Ridge Homes for SaleSarita Addition To Broadway Homes for SaleSarita Heights West Homes for SaleSeascape I Condo Homes for SaleSierra Condo Apartments Homes for SaleSouth Fork Estates Homes for SaleSpringtree Homes for SaleSt Lucie Club And Apartment Homes Homes for SaleSt Lucie Estates Homes for SaleSt Lucie Falls (Aka River Forest) Homes for SaleSt Lucie Inlet Farms Homes for SaleSummerfield Homes for SaleSuntide Homes for SaleTall Pines Homes for SaleThe Court Yards Homes for SaleThe Preserve At Park Trace Homes for SaleThe Village Of Stuart Homes for SaleTowne Park Replat Homes for SaleTrailside Homes for SaleTrillium Homes for SaleTwin Lakes South Town Homes for SaleTwin Lakes South Town Villas Homes for SaleVilabella Central Park Homes for SaleVista Pines Homes for SaleWhitemarsh Reserve Homes for SaleWilloughby Homes for SaleWilloughby Townhomes Homes for SaleWoodmill Pond Homes for SaleYacht Club Beach Homes for SaleYacht & Country Club Of S Homes for SaleYacht & Country Club Of Stuart Homes for SaleHighpointe Homes for SaleMariner Sands Homes for SaleSailfish Point Homes for SaleSalerno Reserve At Showcase Homes for SaleSeaside Homes for SaleVista Del Lago Homes for SaleRio Vista Homes for SaleLakeside Condo Irp Homes for SalePoppleton Creek Homes for SaleOcean View Condo Homes for SaleSpringtree Homes for SalePierpoint Yacht Club Homes for SaleDuckwood Homes for SaleTidewater Point Homes for SaleCamellia Homes for SaleRainbow Cove Homes for SaleSt Lucie Park Homes for SaleCourt Yards Homes for SaleNorth River Shores Homes for Sale
Looking to Rent?
Browse all rental listings in Stuart, FL, including homes near Sailfish Cay.