$310,000
Closed
1d
$310,000
4501 Bridgetown
Stuart, FL 34997
2 bd2 ba1,416 sqft
Willoughby Cay
Stuart, FL
Willoughby Cay Homes for Sale
Browse active MLS listings in Willoughby Cay, Stuart, FL. Local expertise, free buyer representation, 1% listing commission.
—
Community Type
Willoughby Cay — Active Listings
0 active listings
No listings found for this search. Contact us for off-market options.
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Willoughby Cay — Recent Sales
6 recent sales
$330,000
Closed
22d
$330,000
1558 Tidewater
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,549 sqft
Willoughby Cay
$325,000
Closed
118d
$325,000
1594 Tidewater
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,549 sqft
Willoughby Cay
$264,900
Closed
27d
$264,900
4620 Bridgetown
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,549 sqft
Willoughby Cay
$325,000
Closed
45d
$325,000
4657 Bridgetown
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,549 sqft
Willoughby Cay
$214,900
Closed
4d
$214,900
4662 Bridgetown
Stuart, FL 34997
3 bd2 ba1,549 sqft
Willoughby Cay
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Home Valuation
What is Your Willoughby Cay Home Worth?
Get a free, no-obligation home valuation from our local Stuart specialists. We'll analyze recent sales and current market conditions to give you an accurate estimate.
Mortgage Pre-Approval
Get Pre-Approved to Buy in Willoughby Cay
Mortgage Capital: FHA, VA, Conventional, Jumbo, DSCR, Non-QM
Looking for Willoughby Cay homes for sale? Pure Equity Realty covers Willoughby Cay and the Stuart, Florida market. We charge 1% listing commission for sellers and provide free buyer representation. Our local agents know this community and can arrange showings within 24 hours.
About Willoughby Cay
Willoughby Cay Community Guide
Willoughby Cay is a residential community in Stuart, Florida.
Pure Equity Realty covers Willoughby Cay and the Stuart area. We list for 1%, which includes photography, MLS syndication, and negotiation support. Buyers pay nothing for representation. For current market data, see Florida Realtors' market statistics.
Age of Homes in Willoughby Cay
Homes listed in Willoughby Cay date from 2003, so they are about 23 years old.
Every one of these homes went up after Florida adopted its statewide building code in 2002. In practice, that usually means impact-rated openings and stronger roof attachment. A wind mitigation inspection documents those features, and Florida insurers must offer premium discounts for them.
South Florida MLS
Featured Willoughby Cay Homes for Sale
0 active listings
No listings found for this search. Contact us for off-market options.
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Location & Map
Willoughby Cay Location
Map is approximate. Contact us for exact community boundaries.
View on Google Maps →Frequently Asked Questions
Willoughby Cay FAQ
What type of community is Willoughby Cay?+
Willoughby Cay is a residential community in Stuart, Florida.
Does Willoughby Cay allow rentals?+
Willoughby Cay currently restricts rentals per HOA rules. This is common in 55+ and gated communities. Exceptions and waiting lists may exist. Contact us for the most up-to-date rental policy details.
How do I schedule a showing in Willoughby Cay?+
Call us at (561) 835-5400 or use the listing alert form on this page. Our agents specialize in Willoughby Cay and the broader Stuart market and can typically arrange private showings within 24 hours, including evenings and weekends.
More Stuart Real Estate
Stuart Property Types & Special Listings
Locations near Willoughby Cay
Castle Hill Homes for SaleCircle Bay Yacht Club Homes for SaleDuckwood Homes for SaleEdgewater Villas Condo Homes for SaleGregor Woods Homes for SaleHaig Point Homes for SaleBroadway St Lucie Estates Homes for SaleHutchinson House West Homes for SaleImperial Apartment Condo Homes for SaleInlet Place Homes for SaleLocks Landing Homes for SaleMariner Sands Country Club Homes for SaleMartins Crossing Homes for SaleOcean View Condo Homes for SaleCamellia Homes for SaleVista Del Lago Homes for SaleYacht Country Club Homes for SaleBroadview Homes for SaleBroadway Section Of St Lucie Estates Subdivision Homes for SaleCocoanut Park Homes for SaleCourtyard at Willoughby Homes for SalePalm Lake Park Homes for SaleDowntown Stuart Homes for SaleBachmann Homes for SaleFairway Apartments Condo In Mariner Sands Homes for SaleCoral Gardens Homes for SaleBeau Rivage Homes for SaleFishermans Village Homes for SaleGolden Gate Park Homes for SaleCivitas Place Condo Homes for SaleFirst Fairway Homes for SalePalmetto Harbor Homes for SaleHildabrad Park Homes for SaleHalf Mile Lake Condo Homes for SalePark Square Condo Aka Country Meadows Homes for SaleHummingbird Place Homes for SaleIndian Groves Homes for SaleBehlaus Homes for SaleGarden Villas North Homes for SaleConquistador Homes for Sale593845 Harbor Estates St Lucie Sett Homes for SaleKingswood Condo 3 Homes for SaleCoral Lakes Homes for SaleBay Colony of Stuart Homes for SaleCoral Point Homes for SalePine Manor Homes for SaleLake Charlotte Homes for SalePinewood Park Homes for SaleCasa Terrace Homes for SaleLake Tuscany Homes for SaleAqua Bonita Homes for SaleBakopoulos Homes for SaleLive Oak Estates Homes for SaleBelle Haven Stuart Homes for SaleLakeside Condo Irp Homes for SalePoppleton Creek Homes for SaleCabana Point Homes for SalePoppleton Creek Area Homes for SaleMariner Sands Homes for SaleDe La Bahia Homes for SalePort Salerno Homes for SalePort Salerno Village Homes for SalePort Sewall Harbor Homes for SaleCedar Pointe Condo Village Homes for SaleFrazier Homes for SaleChatham Homes for SaleLost River Cove Homes for SaleLost River Manor Homes for SaleCypress Point Homes for SaleFlorida Club Homes for SaleFoxcross Homes for SaleEldorado Heights Homes for SaleManatee Creek Homes for SaleMeadowwood Homes for SalePinelake Gardens Estates Homes for SaleMariner Cay 03 Condo Homes for SaleIronwood Mariner San Homes for SaleNorth River Shores Homes for SaleBessey Homes for SaleBessey Addition Homes for SaleHenley Homes for SaleMartin Crossing Homes for SaleMartin Meadows Homes for SaleMartin'S Crossing Homes for SaleFour Winds on River Homes for SaleInlet Harbor Homes for SaleBanyan House Condo Homes for SaleBanyan Tree Estates Homes for SaleHarbour Estates Homes for SaleLawler Heights Homes for SaleColonial Park Homes for SaleBeachwood Villas Homes for SaleOcean Cove Townhomes Homes for SaleHidden Harbour Homes for SaleQueens Park Homes for SaleBrook Villas Homes for SaleMiles Grant Homes for SaleMiles Grant Condo 01 Homes for SaleCedar Pointe Condo Homes for SaleEast Lake Charlotte Estates Homes for Sale800 Place Homes for SaleKingswood Homes for SaleCostner S Homes for SaleRiver House Homes for SaleCombes Homes for SaleConquistador Estates Homes for SaleCoral Gardens Homes for SaleCountry Meadows Condo Homes for SaleCourtyards AT Willoughby Condo Homes for SaleCove At Park Trace Homes for SaleDixie View Homes for SaleCove Lakes Homes for SaleCape Live Oak Homes for SaleSailfish Cove Homes for SaleSalerno Reserve Homes for SaleFairway Villas South Homes for SaleMariners Landing Homes for SaleFishermans Cove Aka Somerset Homes for SaleEventide Homes for SaleFrazier Creek Homes for SaleBanyan Bay Homes for SaleDoubleton Homes for SaleCrestwood Condo Homes for SaleEmerald Lakes Homes for SaleSarita Heights Homes for SaleOakmont Homes for SalePark Square Homes for SaleEstuary At Nrs Homes for SaleCypress Glen Stuart Homes for SaleFern Creek Homes for SaleOcean East Gardens Homes for SaleFork River Homes for SaleSeascape I Condo Homes for SaleBayview Irp Homes for SaleDixie Park Homes for SaleEagles Landing Homes for SaleLocks Estates Homes for SaleMariner Village Homes for SalePlantation House Condo Irp Homes for SaleSt Lucie Estates Homes for SaleHansons Landing Homes for SaleHarborage Yacht Homes for SaleHarborage Yacht Club Homes for SaleSierra Condo Apartments Homes for SaleOak Hammock Homes for SaleHorseshoe Point Homes for SaleBoggans Homes for SaleBuena Park Homes for SaleCaribbean Key Homes for SaleHunter Lake Homes for SaleHutchinson House Homes for SaleMontego Cove Condo All Homes for SaleInlet Village North Condo Ph 01 Irp Homes for SaleIronwood In Mariner Sands Homes for SaleMurray Cove Homes for SaleJames Villa Homes for SaleSylvan Shores Homes for SaleKanner Lake (Aka Willow Pointe) Homes for SaleKing Mountain Condo Monterey Yacht & Country Club Homes for SaleFinlandia Quarters Villas Condo Homes for SaleEvans Estates Homes for SaleKrueger Estate Homes for SaleNorthwood Homes for SaleSouthwood Pud Homes for SaleFairway Condos Homes for SaleFairway Palms Homes for SaleRiverland Homes for SaleSt Lucie Falls (Aka River Forest) Homes for SaleSt Lucie Inlet Farms Homes for SaleOsprey Ridge Stuart Homes for SaleFishermans Cove Homes for SaleLegacy Cove Homes for SalePepperwood Homes for SaleLeisure Village Homes for SaleLexington Lakes Homes for SaleFishermans Hideaway Homes for SaleFishermans Paradise Homes for SaleRustic Acres Homes for SalePierpoint Yacht Club Homes for SalePine Castle Homes for SaleLincoln Park Stuart Homes for SaleParkview Condo Homes for SaleSandpiper Square Homes for SaleLost River Manors Homes for SaleSarita Heights West Homes for SaleStypmann Park First Homes for SaleNorth River Forest Homes for SaleOcean Cove Homes for SalePinelake Gardens And Estates Homes for SaleManatee Isles Homes for SaleMariner Village Of Martin County Homes for SaleGlenridge Homes for SaleFoxwood Homes for SaleEdgewater Pointe Homes for SaleMariner Cay Homes for SaleMariner Sands Club Villas Homes for SaleMariner Sands Club Villas Condo Homes for SaleGalleon Bay Homes for SaleMonterey Homes for SaleHibiscus Park Homes for SaleGardens At Poppleton Creek Homes for SaleMichaels Square Homes for SaleParkwood Homes for SaleGolden Gate Homes for SaleHutchinson House East Homes for SaleMontego Cove Homes for SaleSnug Harbor West Homes for SaleSunset Estates Stuart Homes for SaleNatalie Estates Homes for SaleNatalie Estates Mobile Home Park Co Op Homes for SaleNew Monrovia Homes for SaleSunshine Manor Mobile Home Park Homes for SaleNorth Pointe Town Homes Homes for SaleRainbow Cove Homes for SaleNortons Landing Homes for SaleSuntide Homes for SaleSpringtree Homes for SaleHammocks South Homes for Sale1500 Se Cove Road Homes for SaleSt Lucie Club And Apartment Homes Homes for SaleSt Lucie Falls Homes for SaleSt Lucie Point Homes for SaleSt Lucie Settlement Homes for SaleDutcher Estates Homes for SaleTall Pines Stuart Homes for SaleOcean Isle Condo Homes for SaleRio Vista Sub Homes for SaleHoliday Country Club Homes for SaleRiver Marina Townhomes Homes for SaleMeyer Estates Homes for SalePreserves At Park Trace Homes for SaleHidden Harbor Condo Homes for SaleOsceola Place Condo Homes for SaleSummerfield Homes for SaleTidewater Court Homes for SaleRuff'S Little Dixie Homes for SaleKing Mountain Condo (Aka Monterey Yacht & Country Homes for SaleKingman Acres Homes for SalePort Sewall (Aka Sewall'S Point Land Co) Homes for SaleSchaeffers Homes for SaleParamount Estates Homes for SaleTerrace Gardens Homes for SaleRiver Glen Homes for SaleSherwood Forest Homes for SaleSierra Condos Homes for SaleRiver Pines Homes for SalePreserves of Park Trace Homes for SaleRiver Ridge Homes for SalePinelakes Gardens Estates Homes for SalePlerpoint Yacht Club Homes for SaleSouthern Isle Condo Homes for SaleRand Point Homes for SaleSouthwood Homes for SaleHarbor Front Homes for SalePutnam Homes for SaleKing Mountain Homes for SaleCourt Yards Homes for SaleLake Haven Homes for SaleCove Royale Homes for SaleLake Clare Homes for SaleCoventry Stuart Homes for SaleResort Villas Homes for SaleResort Villas Condo 01 & 02 Irp Homes for SaleRio Vista Homes for SaleMcdonalds Homes for SaleRiver Forest Homes for SaleRiver Marina Homes for SaleRiverside Park Homes for SaleRiver Point Homes for SaleRiver Shores Plantation Homes for SaleRoyal Oak Towers Homes for SaleRocky Point Homes for SaleRuffs Little Dixie Homes for SaleStuart Cay Homes for SaleSandpebble Homes for SaleSandy Ridge Homes for SaleThe Preserve At Avonlea Homes for SaleSarita Addition To Broadway Homes for SaleSavannah Estates Homes for SaleSawtell Homes for SaleLocks Pointe Homes for SaleWaterford Homes Homes for SaleCongressional Place Homes for SaleSierra Condo Apts Homes for SaleSouth Fork Estates Homes for SaleFairmont Estates Homes for SaleThe Woodlands Homes for SaleSnug Harbor 3 Homes for SaleEdgewater Villas Homes for SaleSouth River Colony Homes for SaleSpringtree Homes for Sale800 Place Stuart Homes for SaleSouthern Pines Homes for SaleSt Lucie Club Homes for SaleTown Park North 2 Homes for SaleSt Lucie Club Apt Homes Homes for SaleSt Lucie Park Homes for SaleHalpatiokee Park Homes for SaleThe Village Of Stuart Homes for SaleTidewater Point Homes for SaleTidewater Pointe Homes for SaleHabitat Village Homes for SaleTierra Verde Condo 07 Homes for SaleTiffany Condominiums Homes for SaleTimber Trail Homes for SaleTall Pines Homes for SaleThe Preserve At Park Trace Homes for SaleTowne Park North Condo Homes for SaleTowne Park Replat Homes for SaleTierra Verde Homes for SaleTierra Verde Stuart Homes for SaleShurwood Gardens Homes for SaleThe Champion Club Homes for SaleThe Court Yards Homes for SaleTrailside Homes for SaleThe Cove at Park Trace Homes for SaleSouth River Village Homes for SaleIndian Pines Homes for SaleTropic Breeze Estates Homes for SaleThe Estates Homes for SaleThe Estuary Homes for SaleTropical Estates Homes for SaleTropical Farms Homes for SaleTres Belle Homes for SaleTwin Lakes South Town Homes for SaleTwin Lakes South Town Villas Homes for SaleTwin Oaks Homes for SaleTropical Paradise Homes for SaleValor Point Homes for SaleCove Isle Homes for SaleTownhomes of Stuart Homes for SaleTwin Lakes Stuart Homes for SaleVilabella Homes for SaleTrillium Homes for SaleTropic Acres Homes for SaleVilabella Central Park Homes for SaleTropical Fruit Farms Homes for SaleWilloughby Aka Willoughby Cay Homes for SaleSailfish Cay Homes for SaleVillage Oaks Homes for SaleSeaside Homes for SaleVillage Stuart Condo Homes for SaleVillage of Stuart Homes for SaleVista Pines Homes for SaleVista Salerno Homes for SaleWaco Field Place Homes for SaleWalton Manor Homes for SaleWashington Park Salerno Homes for SaleWestwood Homes for SaleLawn Lake Homes for SaleWhispering Pines Homes for SaleWhitemarsh Preserve Homes for SaleWhitemarsh Reserve Homes for SaleWildwood Estates Homes for SaleWilloughby Glen Homes for SaleWilloughby Homes for SaleWilloughby Aka Willoughby Glen Homes for SaleWilloughby Crescent Homes for SaleWilloughby Golf Club Homes for SaleWilloughby Townhomes Homes for SaleWillow Lake Trail Homes for SaleWillow Pointe Homes for SaleWindjammer Homes for SaleWinged Foot Cottages Homes for SaleWoodmere Meadows Homes for SaleWoodmill Homes for SaleWoodmill Pond Homes for SaleWrights Homes for SaleYacht Club Beach Homes for SaleYacht & Country Club Of S Homes for SaleYacht & Country Club Of Stuart Homes for SaleYacht & Country Club Stuart Homes for SaleSailfish Point Homes for SaleHighpointe Homes for SaleSalerno Reserve At Showcase Homes for Sale
Looking to Rent?
Browse all rental listings in Stuart, FL, including homes near Willoughby Cay.