$250,000
Closed
16d
$250,000
2369 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
Jensen Beach, FL
Fishermans Haven Homes for Sale
Browse active MLS listings in Fishermans Haven, Jensen Beach, FL. Local expertise, free buyer representation, 1% listing commission.
—
Community Type
Fishermans Haven — Active Listings
0 active listings
No listings found for this search. Contact us for off-market options.
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Fishermans Haven — Recent Sales
25 recent sales
$249,000
Closed
12d
$249,000
2290 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$245,000
Closed
3d
$245,000
2229 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
3 bd1.5 ba1,073 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$265,000
Closed
135d
$265,000
2229 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
3 bd1.5 ba1,189 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$199,888
Closed
11d
$199,888
2199 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$220,000
Closed
5d
$220,000
2116 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba1,073 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$220,000
Closed
7d
$220,000
2126 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$239,000
Closed
$239,000
2359 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba1,073 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$175,000
Closed
33d
$175,000
2280 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$175,000
Closed
2d
$175,000
2229 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1.5 ba1,073 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$155,000
Closed
1d
$155,000
2269 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1.5 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$139,000
Closed
2d
$139,000
2155 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$125,900
Closed
2d
$125,900
2340 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$280,000
Closed
54d
$280,000
2405 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
4 bd2.5 ba1,686 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$280,000
Closed
14d
$280,000
2406 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1.5 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$125,000
Closed
5d
$125,000
2259 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$129,000
Closed
6d
$129,000
2375 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$22,888
Closed
6d
$22,888
2316 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba1,073 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$112,800
Closed
71d
$112,800
2190 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$97,500
Closed
14d
$97,500
2206 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$107,900
Closed
8d
$107,900
2105 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba1,073 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$195,000
Closed
19d
$195,000
2196 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
4 bd2 ba843 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$109,900
Closed
45d
$109,900
2275 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
3 bd1 ba1,073 sqft
Fishermans Haven
$69,900
Closed
87d
$69,900
2275 Rustic
Jensen Beach, FL 34957
2 bd1 ba1,073 sqft
Fishermans Haven
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Home Valuation
What is Your Fishermans Haven Home Worth?
Get a free, no-obligation home valuation from our local Jensen Beach specialists. We'll analyze recent sales and current market conditions to give you an accurate estimate.
Mortgage Pre-Approval
Get Pre-Approved to Buy in Fishermans Haven
Mortgage Capital: FHA, VA, Conventional, Jumbo, DSCR, Non-QM
Looking for Fishermans Haven homes for sale? Pure Equity Realty covers Fishermans Haven and the Jensen Beach, Florida market. We charge 1% listing commission for sellers and provide free buyer representation. Our local agents know this community and can arrange showings within 24 hours.
About Fishermans Haven
Fishermans Haven Community Guide
Fishermans Haven is a residential community in Jensen Beach, Florida.
Pure Equity Realty covers Fishermans Haven and the Jensen Beach area. We list for 1%, which includes photography, MLS syndication, and negotiation support. Buyers pay nothing for representation. For current market data, see Florida Realtors' market statistics.
Renting and Investing in Fishermans Haven
Rentals in Fishermans Haven have a median asking rent of $2,200 per month, across 1 active rental listing. For comparison, the Jensen Beach median is $3,450, so rents here run 36% lower.
You can browse current Jensen Beach rentals or ask us for a rent estimate on a specific Fishermans Haven home.
South Florida MLS
Featured Fishermans Haven Homes for Sale
0 active listings
No listings found for this search. Contact us for off-market options.
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Location & Map
Fishermans Haven Location
Map is approximate. Contact us for exact community boundaries.
View on Google Maps →Frequently Asked Questions
Fishermans Haven FAQ
What type of community is Fishermans Haven?+
Fishermans Haven is a residential community in Jensen Beach, Florida.
Does Fishermans Haven allow rentals?+
Fishermans Haven currently restricts rentals per HOA rules. This is common in 55+ and gated communities. Exceptions and waiting lists may exist. Contact us for the most up-to-date rental policy details.
How do I schedule a showing in Fishermans Haven?+
Call us at (561) 835-5400 or use the listing alert form on this page. Our agents specialize in Fishermans Haven and the broader Jensen Beach market and can typically arrange private showings within 24 hours, including evenings and weekends.
More Jensen Beach Real Estate
Condos in Jensen BeachWaterfront Homes in Jensen BeachGated Communities in Jensen BeachGolf Communities in Jensen Beach55+ Communities in Jensen BeachNew Construction Homes in Jensen BeachLuxury Homes in Jensen BeachOceanfront Properties in Jensen BeachEquestrian Communities in Jensen BeachTennis Communities in Jensen Beach
Jensen Beach Property Types & Special Listings
Bank-Owned Homes (REOs) in Jensen BeachShort Sales in Jensen BeachMulti-Family Homes in Jensen BeachDuplexes in Jensen BeachTriplexes in Jensen BeachQuadplexes in Jensen BeachMobile & Manufactured Homes in Jensen BeachHUD Homes in Jensen BeachFor Sale By Owner in Jensen BeachForeclosures in Jensen BeachHome Auctions in Jensen BeachRent to Own Homes in Jensen Beach
Locations near Fishermans Haven
10 Minutes To The Ocean Homes for SaleJensen Beach Golf And Country Club Homes for SaleJensen Park Estates Homes for SaleMiramar Homes for SaleOcean Bay Villas Homes for SaleOceana Oceanfront Homes for SaleOutdoor Resorts At Nettle Homes for SaleBeach Club Colony Homes for SaleDiamond Sands Homes for SaleBallantine Moore Homes for SaleBay Tree Homes for SaleBlue Heron Mobile Home Park Co Op Homes for SaleHoliday Out At St Lucie Inc Homes for SaleHolly Creek Homes for SaleAvila Homes for SaleIndian River Waterfront Homes for SaleJensen Beach Golf Country Club 05 Homes for SaleJensen Beach Homesites Homes for SaleIsland Beach Club A Homes for SaleJensen Village Homes for SaleIsland Crest Homes for SaleIslandia Homes for SaleBanyan Terrace Cotta Homes for SalePine Grove Homes for SalePinecrest Lakes Homes for SaleAtlantis Condominium Building A Homes for SalePitchford Minor Homes for SaleHoliday Out At St Lucie Sec B Homes for SalePond Ridge Villas East Homes for SaleDune Walk Homes for SaleLangford Landing Homes for SaleAncora Residences Homes for SaleCerro De Santa Cruz Homes for SaleDesteubens Sub Homes for SaleDune Homes for SaleIndian River Point Homes for SaleJensen Beach Country Club Homes for SaleAtlantis Iii By The Sea A Homes for SaleRegency Island Dunes Homes for SaleBeau Rivage East Homes for SaleBlue Diamond Fruit Homes for SaleBrennan Court Homes for SalePrincess Homes for SalePrincess Of Hutchinson Island Homes for SaleOceana Oceanfront Condomi Homes for SaleAdmiral Homes for SaleMiramar Ii, The Homes for SaleHurchanick Heights Homes for SaleMiramar Royale Homes for SaleOsprey Preserve Rpud Homes for SaleRio Homes for SaleRio St Lucie Homes for SaleCinnamon Tree Homes for SalePepper Park Homes for SaleCoconut Way Homes for SaleRiverlight Homes for SaleJensen Beach Club Homes for SaleCorona Del Rio Homes for SaleBeacon Homes for SaleNewport Jensen Rev Homes for SaleCross Roads Hill Homes for SaleSavanna Hills Homes for SaleSavanna Oaks Homes for SaleDreyer Haven Minor Homes for SaleEden Refuge Homes for SaleOcean Breeze West Homes for SalePineapple Plantation Homes for SalePineapple Plantation (Aka Pines) Homes for SaleOceanrise Homes for SaleArch Heights Homes for SaleSunny Acres Homes for SalePortofino at Jensen Homes for SalePortofino At Jensen Beach Homes for SaleMango Lane Homes for SaleSilas Minor Homes for SaleHoliday Out At St Lucie Section B Homes for SaleIndian River Villas Homes for SaleIsland Club Homes for SaleJensen Park Villas Homes for SaleMiramar The Homes for SaleMeyers Minor Homes for SaleIsland Village Homes for SaleMiramar Ii Homes for SaleOcean Breeze Resort Homes for SaleFairwinds Cove Homes for SaleOceana South Homes for SaleLeilani Heights Homes for SalePalm Circle Mh Homes for SaleOcean Bay Villas A Condominium Homes for SalePinelake Village Homes for SaleThe Falls Of Jensen Beach Homes for SaleFour Fish Condos Homes for SaleOcean Towers Condo A Homes for SaleOaklane Manor Homes for SaleRegency Homes for SaleMiller S Subdivision Homes for SaleOaks Indian River Homes for SaleNewport Jensen Aka Indian River Point Homes for SalePitchman Minor Homes for SaleEagle Marsh Homes for SaleGreen Turtle Cove Homes for SaleHansen Heights Homes for SaleSt Lucie River Heights Homes for SaleOcean Dunes Homes for SaleOcean Towers Condo B Homes for SaleOcean Towers Homes for SaleOsprey Preserve Homes for SaleOutrigger Harbour Homes for SaleOutdoor Resorts At Nettles Island Homes for SalePetermans Homes for SaleSago Sands Homes for SaleSailfish Village At Beacon Homes for SalePineapple Bluff Homes for SalePalmetto Grove Homes for SaleSavanna Highlands Homes for SaleParadise Lakes Homes for SaleIndian River Landing Homes for SaleSabal Pointe Homes for SalePelican Pointe West Homes for SalePine Crest Lakes Homes for SaleBahama Terrace Homes for SaleLake Manor Park Homes for SalePrincess Of Hutchinson Is Homes for SaleSt Lucie Vista Estate Homes for SaleSand Dollar Villas Condominium B Homes for SaleSkyline Park Homes for SaleIsland Dunes Homes for SaleRenar River Place Homes for SaleResubdivision Of 9 10 37 Homes for SaleRio St Lucie Terrace Homes for SaleSkyline Gardens Homes for SaleRiver Club Homes for SaleRiver Club Jensen Beach Homes for SaleIndian Ridge Homes for SaleRiver Terrace Homes for SaleRiver Vista Homes for SaleBallantine and Moore 2 Homes for SaleRiverside Heights Homes for SaleSkyline Heights Homes for SaleIsland Dunes Condo A Homes for SaleGaines Estate Homes for SaleSavannas Club Homes for SaleThe Pines - Pineapple Plantation Homes for SaleSand Dollar Villas Condominium C Homes for SaleLegion Heights Homes for SaleThe Reserve at Windemere Homes for SaleSea Winds Homes for SaleSeaview Terrace Homes for SaleSeawalk Homes for SaleBlue Heron Cottages Mobile Home Homes for SaleJensen Highlands Homes for SaleSpring Hill Jensen Beach Homes for SaleFalls Homes for SaleSouth Jensen Heights Homes for SaleThe Preserve at Rio Homes for SaleSugarhill Homes for SaleTimberwick Homes for SaleTown Country Estates Homes for SaleTropical Acres Homes for SaleTropical Acres Mhp Co Op Homes for SaleVenture Out At Indian River Inc Sec D Homes for SaleVenture Out Sec C Homes for SaleIndian River Gardens Homes for SaleIsland Dunes Oceanside Homes for SaleVilla Del Sol Condominium Homes for SaleWaverly Heights Homes for SaleWest Jensen Homes for SaleWest Jensen Highland Homes for SaleLa Tierra Homes for SaleWindmill Village By The Sea Condo Homes for Sale
Looking to Rent?
Browse all rental listings in Jensen Beach, FL, including homes near Fishermans Haven.