$275,000
Active
$275,000
250 JOHN F KENNEDY #107
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,421 sqft
Atlantis Sherbrooke Villas East Condo
Atlantis, FL
Colony Key Villas Homes for Sale
Browse active MLS listings in Colony Key Villas, Atlantis, FL. Local expertise, free buyer representation, 1% listing commission.
—
Community Type
Colony Key Villas — Active Listings
26 active listings
$189,900
Active
1d
$189,900
169 Atlantis #302
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,200 sqft
Atlantis Regency Condo
$1,475,000
Active
5d
$1,475,000
586 Country Club
Atlantis, FL 33462
4 bd3.5 ba3,504 sqft
Atlantis
$1,937,000
Active
5d
$1,937,000
460 Glenbrook
Atlantis, FL 33462
4 bd4.5 ba3,684 sqft
Atlantis City Of 16-B
$193,900
Active
11d
$193,900
6164 Ironwood
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2 ba1,832 sqft
Maralago Cay
$379,933
Active
12d
$379,933
415 Pine Tree #16
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,222 sqft
Tudors In The Pines Condo
$310,000
Active
17d
$310,000
250 John F Kennedy #204
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,470 sqft
Atlantis Sherbrooke Villas East Condo
$919,000
Active
7d
$919,000
244 Walton-Heath
Atlantis, FL 33462
4 bd4 ba2,678 sqft
City Of Atlantis
$519,500
Active
14d
$519,500
362 Yorktowne
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,750 sqft
Atlantis
$299,000
Active
7d
$299,000
340 Orange Tree #5
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,269 sqft
Tudor Two South Condos
$145,000
Active
54d
$145,000
4165 3rd
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2 ba1,500 sqft
Maralago Cay
$1,299,000
Active
50d
$1,299,000
341 Glenbrook
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd3 ba3,165 sqft
Atlantis City Of 14a
$269,000
Active
52d
$269,000
157 Atlantis #301
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,421 sqft
Atlantis Regency Garden Apts Condo
$624,900
Active
89d
$624,900
437 French Royale
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2 ba2,159 sqft
French Royale Villas
$614,900
Active
91d
$614,900
117 Palm
Atlantis, FL 33462
4 bd3 ba2,817 sqft
Palms At Atlantis
$68,000
Active
94d
$68,000
6385 Cypress
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,360 sqft
Mara Lago Cay
$50,000
Active
98d
$50,000
6059 Palm Harbour
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,250 sqft
Palm Breezes Club
$145,000
Active
61d
$145,000
6289 Lear #302
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba756 sqft
Mariner Iv Condo
$49,900
Active
27d
$49,900
6445 Cypress
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,240 sqft
Maralago Cay
$185,000
Active
130d
$185,000
169 Atlantis #205
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,200 sqft
Atlantis Regency Condo
$799,000
Active
104d
$799,000
233 Rio Vista #233
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2.5 ba2,054 sqft
Rio Vista Villas
$869,000
Active
115d
$869,000
181 Atlantis #C
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2.5 ba3,038 sqft
Carillon Condo
$299,999
Active
94d
$299,999
324 Orange Tree #4
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,170 sqft
Tudor Two North Condos
$74,900
Active
133d
$74,900
3428 Seacoast #Lot 114
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,600 sqft
Palm Breezes Club
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Colony Key Villas — Recent Sales
888 recent sales
$440,000
Closed
18d
$440,000
428 Pine Villa
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,988 sqft
Pine Villas 9
$649,900
Closed
5d
$649,900
429 Pine Villa
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 ba2,661 sqft
Pine Villas 9
$535,000
Closed
24d
$535,000
433 Pine Villa
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,923 sqft
Pine Villas 10
$175,000
Closed
24d
$175,000
5917 Vía Vermilya #406
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,130 sqft
Olympus Village Condo
$475,000
Closed
44d
$475,000
103 Villa
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,465 sqft
Atlantis Villas
$425,000
Closed
17d
$425,000
3823 Chickasha
Atlantis, FL 33462
4 bd2 ba1,140 sqft
Seminole Manor 2
$330,000
Closed
69d
$330,000
9 Atrium #C
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2.5 ba1,680 sqft
Atlantis Atriums
$769,900
Closed
85d
$769,900
229 Walton Heath
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2.5 ba2,028 sqft
Atlantis
$899,000
Closed
40d
$899,000
320 Country Club
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd3 ba2,771 sqft
Atlantis 1 City Of
$829,000
Closed
32d
$829,000
225 Orange Tree
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,949 sqft
Atlantis 2 City Of
$439,000
Closed
11d
$439,000
446 Pine Villa
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,923 sqft
Pine Villas 10
$689,900
Closed
13d
$689,900
351 Colony Key
Atlantis, FL 33462
4 bd2 ba2,179 sqft
Colony Key Villas At Atlantis
$539,000
Closed
67d
$539,000
383 Villa
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,916 sqft
French Royale Villas At Atlantis
$257,143
Closed
42d
$257,143
324 Orange Tree #5
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,170 sqft
Tudor Two North Condos
$1,497,000
Closed
40d
$1,497,000
513 Country Club
Atlantis, FL 33462
5 bd4.5 ba4,279 sqft
City Of Atlantis
$1,979,000
Closed
10d
$1,979,000
228 Orange Tree
Atlantis, FL 33462
5 bd4 ba4,556 sqft
Atlantis 4 City Of
$700,000
Closed
$700,000
322 Cedar Key
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,819 sqft
Cedar Key Vill
$988,120
Closed
54d
$988,120
455 Country Club
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd3 ba2,679 sqft
Atlantis 8 City Of
$1,050,000
Closed
39d
$1,050,000
413 Country Club
Atlantis, FL 33462
4 bd3 ba2,480 sqft
Atlantis
$1,649,000
Closed
10d
$1,649,000
208 Turnberry
Atlantis, FL 33462
4 bd4 ba4,112 sqft
Atlantis City Of 17
$1,295,000
Closed
37d
$1,295,000
110 Glenbrook
Atlantis, FL 33462
5 bd4.5 ba3,653 sqft
City Of Atlantis
$620,000
Closed
8d
$620,000
720 Muirfield
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2 ba2,152 sqft
Muirfield Villas
$925,000
Closed
12d
$925,000
220 Walton Heath
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2 ba2,121 sqft
Atlantis
$445,000
Closed
31d
$445,000
609 Cypress Key
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2 ba2,096 sqft
Cypress Key Villas
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Home Valuation
What is Your Colony Key Villas Home Worth?
Get a free, no-obligation home valuation from our local Atlantis specialists. We'll analyze recent sales and current market conditions to give you an accurate estimate.
Mortgage Pre-Approval
Get Pre-Approved to Buy in Colony Key Villas
Mortgage Capital: FHA, VA, Conventional, Jumbo, DSCR, Non-QM
Looking for Colony Key Villas homes for sale? Pure Equity Realty covers Colony Key Villas and the Atlantis, Florida market. We charge 1% listing commission for sellers and provide free buyer representation. Our local agents know this community and can arrange showings within 24 hours.
About Colony Key Villas
Colony Key Villas Community Guide
Colony Key Villas is a residential community in Atlantis, Florida. Active listings are currently priced from $50K–$1.9M.
Pure Equity Realty covers Colony Key Villas and the Atlantis area. We list for 1%, which includes photography, MLS syndication, and negotiation support. Buyers pay nothing for representation. For current market data, see Florida Realtors' market statistics.
South Florida MLS
Featured Colony Key Villas Homes for Sale
26 active listings
$275,000
Active
$275,000
250 JOHN F KENNEDY #107
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,421 sqft
Atlantis Sherbrooke Villas East Condo
$189,900
Active
1d
$189,900
169 Atlantis #302
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,200 sqft
Atlantis Regency Condo
$1,475,000
Active
5d
$1,475,000
586 Country Club
Atlantis, FL 33462
4 bd3.5 ba3,504 sqft
Atlantis
$1,937,000
Active
5d
$1,937,000
460 Glenbrook
Atlantis, FL 33462
4 bd4.5 ba3,684 sqft
Atlantis City Of 16-B
$193,900
Active
11d
$193,900
6164 Ironwood
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2 ba1,832 sqft
Maralago Cay
$379,933
Active
12d
$379,933
415 Pine Tree #16
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,222 sqft
Tudors In The Pines Condo
$310,000
Active
17d
$310,000
250 John F Kennedy #204
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,470 sqft
Atlantis Sherbrooke Villas East Condo
$919,000
Active
7d
$919,000
244 Walton-Heath
Atlantis, FL 33462
4 bd4 ba2,678 sqft
City Of Atlantis
$519,500
Active
14d
$519,500
362 Yorktowne
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,750 sqft
Atlantis
$299,000
Active
7d
$299,000
340 Orange Tree #5
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,269 sqft
Tudor Two South Condos
$145,000
Active
54d
$145,000
4165 3rd
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2 ba1,500 sqft
Maralago Cay
$1,299,000
Active
50d
$1,299,000
341 Glenbrook
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd3 ba3,165 sqft
Atlantis City Of 14a
$269,000
Active
52d
$269,000
157 Atlantis #301
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,421 sqft
Atlantis Regency Garden Apts Condo
$624,900
Active
89d
$624,900
437 French Royale
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2 ba2,159 sqft
French Royale Villas
$614,900
Active
91d
$614,900
117 Palm
Atlantis, FL 33462
4 bd3 ba2,817 sqft
Palms At Atlantis
$68,000
Active
94d
$68,000
6385 Cypress
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,360 sqft
Mara Lago Cay
$50,000
Active
98d
$50,000
6059 Palm Harbour
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,250 sqft
Palm Breezes Club
$145,000
Active
61d
$145,000
6289 Lear #302
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba756 sqft
Mariner Iv Condo
$49,900
Active
27d
$49,900
6445 Cypress
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,240 sqft
Maralago Cay
$185,000
Active
130d
$185,000
169 Atlantis #205
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,200 sqft
Atlantis Regency Condo
$799,000
Active
104d
$799,000
233 Rio Vista #233
Atlantis, FL 33462
3 bd2.5 ba2,054 sqft
Rio Vista Villas
$869,000
Active
115d
$869,000
181 Atlantis #C
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2.5 ba3,038 sqft
Carillon Condo
$299,999
Active
94d
$299,999
324 Orange Tree #4
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,170 sqft
Tudor Two North Condos
$74,900
Active
133d
$74,900
3428 Seacoast #Lot 114
Atlantis, FL 33462
2 bd2 ba1,600 sqft
Palm Breezes Club
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Beaches MLS, Inc.
Amenities & Community Details
Colony Key Villas Amenities
Active Price Range
$50K–$1.9M
Colony Key Villas is a residential community in Atlantis. Call (561) 835-5400 for a current amenities list and availability.
Location & Map
Colony Key Villas Location
Map is approximate. Contact us for exact community boundaries.
View on Google Maps →Frequently Asked Questions
Colony Key Villas FAQ
What type of community is Colony Key Villas?+
Colony Key Villas is a residential community in Atlantis, Florida.
What is the price range in Colony Key Villas?+
Homes in Colony Key Villas are currently listed from $50K–$1.9M. Prices shift with market conditions. Contact us or set a listing alert on this page for real-time availability and accurate pricing from our local Atlantis specialists.
Does Colony Key Villas allow rentals?+
Colony Key Villas currently restricts rentals per HOA rules. This is common in 55+ and gated communities. Exceptions and waiting lists may exist. Contact us for the most up-to-date rental policy details.
How do I schedule a showing in Colony Key Villas?+
Call us at (561) 835-5400 or use the listing alert form on this page. Our agents specialize in Colony Key Villas and the broader Atlantis market and can typically arrange private showings within 24 hours, including evenings and weekends.
More Atlantis Real Estate
Atlantis Property Types & Special Listings
Bank-Owned Homes (REOs) in AtlantisShort Sales in AtlantisMulti-Family Homes in AtlantisDuplexes in AtlantisTriplexes in AtlantisQuadplexes in AtlantisMobile & Manufactured Homes in AtlantisHUD Homes in AtlantisFor Sale By Owner in AtlantisForeclosures in AtlantisHome Auctions in AtlantisRent to Own Homes in Atlantis
Locations near Colony Key Villas
French Royal Homes for SaleMuirfield Villas Homes for SaleTudor In The Pines Homes for SaleArcanum Homes for SalePine Villas Homes for SaleAtlantis Atriums Homes for SaleAtlantis Custom Homes Homes for SaleAtlantis Estates Homes for SaleAtlantis Regency East Homes for SaleAtlantis Regency Homes for SaleAtlantis Villas Homes for SaleCarillon Condos Homes for SaleCedar Key Homes for SaleCypress Key Villas Homes for SaleDriftwood Homes for SaleEastwind of Atlantis Homes for SaleFairview of Atlantis Homes for SaleForestview Villas Homes for SaleFoursome at Atlantis Homes for SaleRio Vista Atlantis Homes for SaleSherbrooke Villas South Homes for SaleSherbrooke Villas Homes for SaleTudor North Homes for SaleTudor South Homes for SaleTudor Two Homes for SaleTurnberry Estates Homes for SaleWoodland Villas Homes for SaleYorktowne Homes for SaleAtlantis Regency Garden Apts Homes for SalePalms At Atlantis Homes for SaleAtlantis Sherbrooke Villas East Homes for SaleTudors In The Pines Homes for SalePalm Breezes Club Homes for Sale
Looking to Rent?
Browse all rental listings in Atlantis, FL, including homes near Colony Key Villas.